How Good Revolutions Go Bad

The Obama phenomenon was supposed to usher in a new era in American politics. We would put behind us all those strident accusations and counter-accusations, the lies and half-truths, the abrogation of power, the trampling of the Constitution. There would be no more Blue states or Red states, only the United States of America, a nation committed to the ideal that human dignity and freedom should be shared by all. We would make hard choices, together, for the sake of the common good. We would have accountability and transparency, respect for law and the traditions of the Republic. We voted for that. We wanted that. Or we said we did.

But there were those who believed in the Divine Right of Rulers and they were unhappy about their loss of power. The new Administration had hardly put Abe Lincoln’s Bible back on the shelf when the catcalls began. The hate-filled rhetoric, the wacky conspiracy theories, and the distortions of truth echoed across the airwaves. It was clear that the GOP and its leadership wanted Obama to fail. They began a drumbeat calibrated to the tenor of fear. The hopeful crowds were replaced by Tea Parties and Town Halls filled with frightened people. Thoughtful debate was hijacked by snarling mobs. Effigies twisted in the wind. Racist paranoia poked its ugly head through the thin topsoil of hope and unity.

But the Republic was not really in danger, not as long as people could say what they believed–or even shout it thoughtlessly for the video cameras. As long as the right of a free people to assemble and seek redress of grievances (real or imagined) from their Government was sacrosanct, then all the Tea Parties on Fox could not conspire to sully Old Glory’s colors. But when the very ones who rose to power by their promise to rebuild the United States of America lose their commitment to its foundational values, the Republic is in very grave danger indeed.

The current debate over health care has taken a very disturbing turn. The AP has a story tonight that quotes House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Majority Leader Steny Hoyer as saying of the rancor: “These disruptions are occurring because opponents are afraid not just of differing views — but of the facts themselves. Drowning out opposing views is simply un-American. Drowning out the facts is how we failed at this task for decades.”

That’s a lie. It was a lie when the Republicans called those of us who were against the Iraq war “traitors.” It’s a lie now.

To his credit, President Obama has disavowed Pelosi and Hoyer’s stupidity, but the damage is done. The rhetoric is spinning out of control and only the Democratic Party can stop it, through a consistent and relentless re-statement of the facts, not by becoming the fulfillment of the Right’s monstrous fantasies. If health care reform fails, because the GOP fear-mongered the American public, then so be it. The Republic will last and we shall fight another day.

But if the notion that freedom of speech (even foolish, blatantly false speech) is “un-American” takes root, then I don’t give a damn about health care reform. For this will no longer be a country worth fighting for, but a country to be fought against. The flag might still be red, white and blue, but it will no longer be an American flag. For what doth it profit a nation to gain health care and to lose its very soul?

The times are perilous. I was with a colleague recently, a decorated Army veteran, an elected official in South Carolina, and an African American. He said he was tired of the Right’s lies, and felt he was being pushed into a corner. “If they think that all liberals are a bunch of pacifist hippies, they are wrong. I’ve got guns and I know how to use them.”

America sits atop a powerkeg, and the only bomb squad we can call is we ourselves. Our first task is to make it abundantly clear that political speech is protected, no matter how vile it is. The second thing we must do is re-start the debate thoughtfully and truthfully.

The Revolution is in danger of going bad, quickly. For the fuse is terribly short.

2 thoughts on “How Good Revolutions Go Bad

  1. Your posts always challenge me, this one to the point of my not quite getting it.

    We can all agree that full-throated, foolish, wrongheaded speech is and always should be protected. No doubt.

    I'm not arguing that such speech should be silenced, and I don't think Pelosi is either. THAT would be un-American.

    What's so disturbing about all of this is the ease with which false, factually unsupported positions can take hold. That feels like a relatively new thing, in this age of echo-chamber news channels and blogs. Facts don't matter any more. It's all about the marketing of an emotion or meme that someone strategically thinks can take hold. The facts of global warming don't matter. The facts of Obama's death squads for grandma don't matter. I could go on and on.

    It's something that I wrote about over and over for three years: Why don't we care about the facts anymore?

    I don't think the Republic is endangered by asking that question.



  2. Maybe I don't get it either, my friend. Reading back on it, perhaps the logic wasn't quite as sound as it seemed when my fingers were slamming the keyboards. Here's what I meant to say:

    If Democrats start sounding (and acting) like the mindless hordes of the GOP, calling protests “un-American” or vaguely threatening to use violence on “them,” (Whoever They are), we are no better than they are.

    The President was masterful today in New Hampshire, and I might note, the audience genuinely appreciative and respectful (though the crowd outside was another matter). His is the lead we have to follow: confront the madness of crowds with a full-court press of facts.

    I have been disappointed many times with Speaker Pelosi's leadership. Her McCarthy-esque outburst only adds one more doubt to my already overflowing garbage can of Pelosi-isms. We must win hearts and minds, and we cannot do that through intimidation or name calling.

    I miss you pal. I was out on the Saluda with a pal this weekend and thought of you. I'm ready for a paddling trip when you are.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s